|

Why You’re Not Ready for a CFO (And What You Actually Need First)

At some point, many six-figure coaches start thinking about getting more strategic financial support. The business is growing. Decisions feel heavier. The pressure is real. So the idea of hiring a CFO comes up.

Maybe a business coach mentioned it. Maybe you saw another coach posting about theirs on Instagram. Maybe you’re just exhausted from carrying all the financial decision-making yourself and thinking, I need someone strategic, not just a bookkeeper.

On paper, it makes sense. In practice? It often happens too early and ends up costing more than just money.

What a CFO Actually Assumes

A CFO’s job is to work with clear, reliable financial information and use it to build strategy. They assume

  • Your books are clean and consistently maintained
  • Your accounts are structured in a way that reflects how your business actually operates
  • The numbers you’re looking at are trustworthy, no caveats, no “I think this is right”
  • Your business model is already financially visible (you know what’s profitable, what’s not, and why)

That’s not a flaw in the role. That’s the foundation CFO-level strategy requires. The issue is that most six-figure coaching businesses aren’t there yet, even if the revenue suggests they should be.

Why Strategy Falls Flat Without a Solid Foundation

When the underlying numbers aren’t reliable, strategy becomes theoretical. You hire a fractional CFO. You’re paying $3k, maybe $5k a month. You’re excited. They ask for your financial reports. You send them what you have, knowing it’s incomplete, slightly outdated, or categorized wrong in places you haven’t had time to fix. They build forecasts and recommendations based on that data. The advice sounds good. The projections look promising.

But when you try to implement it, something feels off. The cash flow doesn’t match the plan. The numbers don’t behave the way the forecast said they would. The strategy doesn’t account for how your business actually moves.

And you’re left wondering: Is the advice wrong, or am I missing something? Usually, it’s neither. The strategy is being built on shaky ground.

The Expensive Mismatch

Here’s the hard part. You’re paying CFO-level rates for strategic thinking but you’re spending half the time gathering information the CFO needs just to do their job. Because without a strong foundation

  • They can’t trust the numbers they’re working from
  • You’re constantly clarifying, correcting, or explaining context
  • Strategic recommendations feel disconnected from your day-to-day reality
  • You still don’t feel confident making decisions

It’s not that the CFO isn’t good at what they do. It’s that the infrastructure needed to support their work doesn’t exist yet. And that gap is expensive, financially and mentally.

The Missing Middle Layer

There’s a stage of financial work that gets skipped in most coaching businesses. It’s not basic bookkeeping (transaction entry, reconciliations, tax prep). And it’s not CFO-level forecasting and strategy. It’s the work of making your financial data actually usable for leadership. That means

  • Structuring your books around how your business really earns and spends money (not generic templates)
  • Translating financial reports into insights you can act on (not raw data you have to decode)
  • Interpreting the numbers through your offers, delivery model, and capacity constraints
  • Proactively spotting pressure points before they become expensive problems
  • Building the reliability and clarity that makes higher-level strategy work later

This is the layer that turns “technically accurate books” into “numbers I can actually lead from.” Without it, you’re trying to build strategy on a foundation that can’t hold it.

What “Ready for a CFO” Actually Looks Like

A business is ready for CFO-level support when

  • The books consistently reflect reality, not just transactions
  • Profitability is visible by offer (you know what’s working and what’s not)
  • Cash flow patterns are understood, not guessed at
  • Financial decisions aren’t being made on instinct or hope
  • You trust the data enough that strategic planning feels grounded, not theoretical

Until then, the most valuable financial work happens closer to the numbers, not 30,000 feet above them.

Why Skipping This Stage Creates More Stress

When coaches jump straight to high-level financial strategy too early, a few things tend to happen:

  • They pay for insight they can’t fully use yet
  • Decisions still feel uncertain because the foundation is shaky
  • They end up back in reactive mode, just with fancier spreadsheets
  • The financial stress doesn’t ease, it just gets more expensive

Not because the CFO’s advice was bad. But because the infrastructure to support that advice wasn’t there. And now you’re paying for two things: the strategy and the scramble to make the strategy workable.

What You Actually Need First

If you’re feeling the pull toward CFO-level support but your numbers still don’t feel solid, you’re not behind. You’re in the middle stage. And this stage matters more than most people realize. What you need isn’t more sophisticated forecasting. It’s someone who can

  • Set up financial systems that actually reflect your business model
  • Interpret your numbers in a way that supports real decisions
  • Spot risks and opportunities before they show up as problems
  • Help you understand what’s sustainable, not just what’s possible

This is the work that makes everything else easier later. It’s not as flashy as having a CFO. But it’s more valuable right now. Because strategy only works when it’s built on something solid.

The Real Question

The question isn’t: Do I need a CFO? It’s: Can I trust my financial foundation enough to build strategy on top of it?

If the answer is no or even “I’m not sure”, then the most strategic move you can make is to get that foundation right first.

Once your numbers are reliable, once your financial picture is clear, once you can see what’s actually happening in your business without guessing, that’s when CFO-level strategy becomes powerful.

Until then, you’re paying for strategy without foundation to support it.

Want this level of clarity in your own business? Start with the Cash Flow Clarity Check. It shows you what I look at first when a coach isn’t sure where they stand financially.

Similar Posts